• Lorem ipsum

Join the Stranger Wine Club!

Natural Wines for the Curious Minds


Brooklyn restaurateur, Andrew Tarlow, and musician and natural wine lover, Dennis “DJ” McNany, have come together to create Stranger Wines, a natural and organic wine shop in the heart of Williamsburg. They take care in selecting wines from small, sustainable producers from across the globe - with an ever-evolving and always interesting selection. Vinyl on display also play throughout the shop to set the tone of the day while you peruse through the endless selection. As the team likes to say “all strangers are welcome”, and all to enjoy! 


Choose from:
Standard "Stranger" Share: 2-3 Bottles - $75
Bottles for everyday enjoyment and those just getting started 

Deluxe "Not A Stranger" Share: 2-4 Bottles - $150
Special bottles that even wine enthusiasts don’t see as often



All wine share members will also receive:

Tasting notes and recommendations from the Stranger Wines & Marlow Collective team

First access and discount to events, classes, and collaborations at Stranger Wines

First to know about future membership offerings



How are the wines selected?
Andrew and DJ taste and hand-select every bottle. The theme of each month will vary based on what the team is currently excited about - whether it’s an emerging region, obscure variety, or bottles that are simply singing at the moment.
Bottles are selected with a preference towards wineries farming organically and fermenting in a zero-to-low intervention method. 
Can I customize my selection?
Andrew and DJ are veterans in the business and are skilled in making sure you are drinking the right types and styles of wines year round. So although you can’t choose your wines, our door and inbox are always open for suggestions!
Where do you deliver / ship to?
We deliver anywhere in Brooklyn and Queens for $10 and offer nationwide shipping to 43 states at standard UPS rates. Please click here for additional shipping information. 
When can I expect my first shipment?
If you sign up within a given calendar month (or have a recurring charge on a given month), you will be eligible to receive goods in the next month. For example, if you signed up in January, the first month you’ll be eligible to receive your subscription goods will be February, etc.
Do I have to be home to accept my shipment?
Legally, yes. All deliveries containing alcohol require an adult signature (21+) upon receipt. You must be at least 21 years of age to purchase and receive wine. If you’re not home then someone will need to be there to sign for it.
What if there’s a problem with my wines? What if I don’t like it?
The Stranger Wine Share is meant to introduce members to all different types and styles of wines from all over the world. Drinking a variety of wines is a great way to identify what wines you love and what wines you may not love as much. With that philosophy in mind, we do not offer refunds for bottles that may not be your jam. But again, our inbox is always open!
This would make a great gift, how can I gift this to a friend or family member?
Absolutely! You have great tastes in gifts and your friends and family should appreciate having you in their life :)
I need to skip a shipment, how do I pause or cancel my subscription?
After signing up, you can manage your subscription through the Table22 Member Portal, where you can skip a month, pause your subscription, cancel or update billing & other account information with the click of a button!
Have a different question?
Feel free to reach out to us at [email protected]!